Market internals · US stocks
Market breadth indicators.
Breadth tells you whether a move in the S&P 500 is shared by most stocks or carried by a few. This guide gives each indicator’s formula, a way to read it against the index, and a short routine. It also says what breadth can’t do: it describes the market now, it doesn’t time it.
Education, not investment advice. Nothing here is a recommendation to buy or sell.
Definition
What is market breadth, and why can it disagree with the index?
Market breadth counts how many stocks take part in a move, not how far the index moved. A day when the S&P 500 rises 1% can be a day when most of its stocks rise, or a day when a handful of giants rise and most stocks fall. Breadth tells the two apart.
They can differ because of how the index is built. S&P Dow Jones Indices lists the S&P 500’s weighting method as float-adjusted market cap: bigger companies count for more. On its page, as of 30 September 2026, the index had 503 constituents and the 10 largest made up 37.3% of its weight.
The S&P 500 Equal Weight Index holds the same companies at a fixed 0.2% each at every quarterly rebalance, so on its page the 10 largest make up 2.7%. Breadth indicators go one step further than equal weight: they simply count stocks.
What would change the read: which stocks you count. An exchange-wide count, an S&P 500 count and a Nasdaq count can give different answers on the same day, so compare like with like.
The indicators
Which market breadth indicators matter, and how is each calculated?
Seven common ones, each with its formula and the question it answers. All are built from each stock’s daily price and volume, so they can be calculated for any group of stocks: an exchange, the S&P 500 or a sector.
Advancers vs decliners
Count of stocks up on the day, count down. Ratio = advancers ÷ decliners. Percent advancing = advancers ÷ (advancers + decliners).
How many stocks took part in today’s move?
Advance-decline line
Yesterday’s value + today’s advancers − today’s decliners, added up day after day.
Is participation building or fading over weeks?
Up volume vs down volume
Shares traded in rising stocks against shares traded in falling stocks.
Was the money behind the move on the up side or the down side?
New highs minus new lows
Stocks at a new 52-week high minus stocks at a new 52-week low.
Are more stocks breaking out or breaking down?
Percent above a moving average
Stocks trading above their 50-day (or 200-day) moving average ÷ all stocks in the group.
How many stocks are in their own uptrend?
McClellan Oscillator
A faster exponential average of daily net advances minus a slower one.
Is the pace of net advances speeding up or slowing?
Breadth thrust
A short-term average of the percent of advancing stocks moving from a low reading to a high one within a few days.
Did buying spread to most stocks at once?
Advancers, decliners and the A/D ratio
The simplest reading: how many stocks closed up and how many closed down. Percent advancing turns it into one number between 0% and 100%, which is easier to compare across days than a raw count.
One day says little. The useful question is whether the count agrees with the index, and whether that agreement holds over several sessions.
The advance-decline line
The A/D line is a running total: each day, add advancers and subtract decliners. It rises when more stocks go up than down, day after day, and falls when the reverse is true.
Its level means nothing on its own, because it depends on the start date and on which stocks are counted. An exchange-wide A/D line and an S&P 500 A/D line can also disagree, since the two count different sets of stocks. Read the direction, and compare it with the index.
Up volume vs down volume
The same idea, weighted by shares traded. A day with more advancers but most volume in falling stocks is a weaker up day than the count alone suggests.
New highs minus new lows
Counts stocks at the extremes of their 52-week range. When the index is near a high but few stocks are, the leadership is thin.
Percent above the 50-day and 200-day average
The share of stocks above their own moving average. The 50-day version moves faster; the 200-day version shows how many stocks are in a longer uptrend.
McClellan Oscillator
Takes daily net advances (advancers minus decliners) and subtracts a slower exponential moving average from a faster one. Above zero, net advances are running ahead of their slower trend; below zero, behind it.
Breadth thrust
A breadth thrust is a fast swing in the share of advancing stocks, from a low reading to a high one within a few days, usually measured on a short moving average. Traders also search for it as the Zweig breadth thrust. We give the definition only; we haven’t tested it.
Equal weight vs cap weight
Not a count, but close: comparing the equal-weight S&P 500 with the cap-weighted one shows whether the average stock is keeping up with the giants. We cover that ratio, with a worked example, in equal weight vs cap weight in the risk-on, risk-off guide.
How to read it
Is the move broad or narrow? Read breadth against the index.
Breadth on its own is half a reading. Put it next to the index and there are four cases. This is a way to describe the market, not a tested rule.
Index up · Breadth up
Broad rally
Most stocks rise with the index. The move does not depend on a few names.
Index up · Breadth down
Narrow rally
A few large stocks carry the index while most stocks lag or fall. The index looks stronger than the average stock.
Index down · Breadth holding
Rotation
The heavyweights fall but most stocks hold up. Money is moving between groups more than leaving stocks.
Index down · Breadth down
Broad selloff
The index and most stocks fall together. The selling is not limited to one group.
The rotation case is the one most often misread. When the largest stocks fall but most stocks hold, the index looks worse than the market underneath it. If breadth then follows the leaders down, the selling has spread.
For the question “is everything down, or one group?” on a red day, see why is the stock market down today.
What would change the read: breadth that stops agreeing with the index for more than a few sessions. One day of disagreement is common; a run of them changes the description.
Market breadth divergence
Do breadth divergences warn of a selloff? What 14 years of data say.
A breadth divergence is the index making a new high while breadth does not. It is often described as a warning. We tested one version of that idea, a “breadth divergence at highs” as defined in our stock market crash indicators study, on daily data from 2 May 2012 to 5 November 2026.
The study measured edge as the chance of an SPY −2% day within 10 sessions after an alert, divided by the same chance on any calm day. It chose each setting on 2012–2019 and checked it unchanged on 2020–2026. It publishes the signal types but not their exact settings.
Breadth divergence at highs, from the study
- 22 versions tested.
- Best version on 2012–2019, where it was chosen: 3.5× edge on 6 alerts.
- Same version on 2020–2026: 2.1× edge on only 3 alerts.
- Only 1 of the 22 versions kept an edge above 1.3× in both periods.
The honest summary is: too few alerts to rely on, and it did not hold up out of sample. That is not the same as “no edge”, but it is not a signal to lean on either.
This result covers the divergence rule as the study defines it. It is not a test of each indicator in this guide, and we don’t claim one.
What would change the read: a version that keeps its edge on many more alerts in years it wasn’t chosen on. Until then, treat a divergence as a description of a narrow market, not a forecast.
Worked example
What did a narrow market look like in the first half of 2023?
January to June 2023
16.9%
S&P 500, first half of 2023
7.0%
S&P 500 Equal Weight Index, same period
98th
S&P DJI’s percentile for the 9.9% cap- vs equal-weight gap in its historical data
Source: S&P Dow Jones Indices, Index Dashboard: S&P 500 Factor Indices, June 2023. Data as of 30 June 2023.
S&P DJI reported that the S&P 500 gained 16.9% in the first half of 2023 and that performance was dominated by the Information Technology sector’s 42.8% total return. The equal-weight version of the same 500 companies gained 7.0%, and S&P DJI put the 9.9% gap at the 98th percentile of its historical data.
This is weight-based evidence, not a stock count: it shows the average stock lagging the cap-weighted index, which is the narrow-rally case above. The equal-weight ratio itself is covered in the risk-on, risk-off guide.
In a period like that, the count-based gauges are what a trader would check next. Did the advance-decline line confirm the index’s highs, or flatten? Were new highs coming from a broad list of stocks or a short one? Was the share of stocks above their 200-day rising with the index?
What would change the read: the equal-weight index catching up with the cap-weighted one, and the counts turning up with it. That is what a narrow rally broadening out looks like.
In Senntric, Sector Performance ranks sectors by return and Relative Performance plots each one against SPY: the sector-level version of the same question, broad or carried by one or two groups. They are sector views, not stock counts.
Before the open or at the close
Which three breadth checks should you run each day?
Three checks, a few minutes, one question each. It is a routine for describing the market, not a trade trigger.
01
Participation vs the index
Compare the percent of advancers, or the advance-decline line, with the index’s own move. Note whether they agree.
The index makes a new high while the A/D line does not, or the reverse.
02
New highs minus new lows
Check whether more stocks are making 52-week highs or 52-week lows, and which way the gap is moving.
New lows growing while the index is still near its high.
03
Percent above the 200-day
Check how many stocks are in their own long-term uptrend, and whether that share is rising or falling.
The share falling for several weeks while the index holds up.
Look for agreement. When two of the three turn the same way together, the description of the market has changed; one alone is often noise.
This fits after the overnight news and data in a pre-market checklist. For other gauges that answer the same question from another angle, see our high beta vs low volatility study and the risk-on, risk-off guide.
Where Senntric fits
Is this move broad, or one or two sectors?
Senntric puts Sector Performance and Relative Performance next to your charts, so you can see whether a move is spread across sectors or carried by one or two. They are sector views, not stock counts. Senntric describes the market; it doesn’t tell you what to trade.
For everything in the workspace, see the platform overview.
Questions traders ask
Market breadth FAQ
What is market breadth?
Market breadth measures how many stocks take part in a market move, rather than how far an index moved. It counts advancing and declining stocks, new highs and new lows, or the share of stocks above a moving average. Because the S&P 500 is weighted by float-adjusted market cap, a few large companies can move the index while most stocks go the other way; breadth shows when that happens.
What is the best market breadth indicator?
No single one. Each answers a different question: the advance-decline line tracks participation over time, new highs minus new lows shows how many stocks are breaking out or down, and the percent above the 200-day shows how many are in their own uptrend. They are more useful read together, and against the index, than any one alone.
What does narrow or negative market breadth mean?
Narrow breadth means a few stocks, usually the largest, are doing most of the work while the average stock lags. Negative breadth usually means more stocks are falling than rising on the day. In the first half of 2023, S&P Dow Jones Indices reported the S&P 500 up 16.9% and the S&P 500 Equal Weight Index up 7.0%, a narrow market by that measure. S&P DJI factor dashboard, June 2023.
How is the advance-decline line calculated?
Start from yesterday’s value, add today’s advancing stocks and subtract today’s declining stocks. Repeat every day, so the line is a running total of net advances. Its level depends on the start date and on which stocks are counted, so traders read its direction and compare it with the index, not the number itself.
Is market breadth a leading indicator?
Treat it as a description of the market now, not a timing signal. In our 14-year crash-indicators study, a breadth divergence at highs (as defined in that study) did not hold up out of sample: the best version chosen on 2012–2019 fired only 3 times in 2020–2026, and only 1 of 22 versions kept an edge above 1.3× in both periods. Senntric study: stock market crash indicators.
Sources
- S&P Dow Jones Indices: S&P 500 (weighting method, constituents, top-10 weight as of 30 Sep 2026)
- S&P Dow Jones Indices: S&P 500 Equal Weight Index (0.2% per company at each quarterly rebalance)
- S&P Dow Jones Indices: Index Dashboard, S&P 500 Factor Indices, June 2023 (data as of 30 June 2023)
- Senntric: Stock market crash indicators, tested on daily closes from 2 May 2012 to 5 November 2026 (section 05)